Best Places to Eat Cherry Pie in the USA

min read
A cherry pie with a slice taken out on a table with cherries, star anise and cinnamon.
BetMGM Feb 10, 2022, 3:47 AM

Think of a pie, the best pie that you’ve ever tasted. It’s got a flakey, buttery crust, a sweet yet tart cherry filling and it reminds you of those Sundays spent with family at Grandma’s house. Cherry pies are an American classic; loved all over the country and served at many bakeries, cafes and bistros. Not everyone does the best cherry pies, however, and finding the ultimate one can feel like Christmas morning for the mouth.

We’ve searched high and low for the best cherry pies in the country and we’re going to let you in on our favorite cherry pie restaurants and spots. As well as our favorite cherry-based online casino games to keep you entertained while you wait.

Sweetie-Licious Bakery, Michigan

Many states across the country can grow cherries, but it takes a certain type of cherry to make the best cherry pie. Anyone who has visited Michigan will tell you that the cherries that they produce here are second to none. In fact, the state produces the most tart cherries in the entire world at around 201 million pounds of cherries a year.

Of course, where there are cherries, there will always be cherry pies, but to whittle down your search area, we advise that you go straight to Sweet-Licious Bakery in DeWitt. Linda Hundt is the owner-baker at this iconic establishment and she’s won plenty of awards for the pies in question. The Cheery Cherry Berry pie is made from a buttery crumble and adds a little blueberry zing into the mix to produce a pie of epic flavors and the ideal balance between tart and sweet. Don’t miss out on this one.

Bea’s Ho-Made Products, Wisconsin

You’ll find the cherry pie of your dreams in laid-back Ellison Bay in far northern Lake Michigan. Whether cherries are in season or not, you’ll find what your heart desires here, and it’s not just the cherry pies that will blow your mind. You’ll be presented by a cinder-block hut that is understated and humble when compared to the delights that hide inside. Bea’s Ho-Made Products stands out in a world where pies seem to get smaller and smaller every year. Bea’s are 10-inches, hand-rolled from scratch, and the crusts are simply laden with lard – each of them should come with a diet warning. This iconic establishment has been treating people’s pallets since 1884 – that’s how good they are.

Crouse Cafe, Iowa

As a whole, Iowa is known for its exceptional cherry pies, but one establishment in Indianola stands out from the rest of the cherry pie-producing spots: Crouse Cafe. It’s undoubtedly one of the best in the state, and in fact, many patrons have called it the best in the world. Cherry pie is their specialty; the tart yet sweet filling is succulent and juicy and the crust is tender and flaky – the best combination. If that isn’t enough to tempt you, the renowned Des Moines Register listed this particular cherry pie in its 100 Things to Eat in Iowa Before You Die.

Grand Traverse Pie Company

The Grand Traverse Pie Company is located in downtown Traverse City, Michigan and they know a thing or two about cherry pies. Most places have one cherry pie that they focus on, but not these guys. Their signature pie is the Grand Traverse Cherry Crumb, handmade from Michigan Montgomery cherries and has a toasty crumb topping. It’s also the “Signature Pie” of the National Cherry Festival held in July every year. That’s not where the cherry pie love ends, however.

You’re probably going to want to take a break from your online casino table games to hear just how many cherry pies this company has on offer! They serve up an incredible variety of 11 cherry pies. This is a place where cherry dreams are made, that’s for sure!

Manny’s Cafeteria & Delicatessen, Chicago

Manny’s Cafeteria & Delicatessen in Chicago is mainly famous for its meat-laden sandwiches (although there are some veggie options). In fact, this is the place that Barack Obama loved to come to eat their corned beef sandwiches. However, it’s another part of their menu that truly shines. Of course, we’re talking about their cherry pie. Handmade with exceptional balance and flavor, an oozy center and a flaky, buttery crust make their cherry pies some of the best out there and it’s always worth leaving space for a couple of slices after your meal.

Play cherry-based casino games with BetMGM

We’re sure that you have cherries on the brain after reading this. If you can’t pop out and grab something from one of the amazing spots that we mentioned above, then you can play slots online with a cherry theme to keep you entertained in the meantime. At BetMGM, we have a huge array of cherry-themed online slots for you to choose from. Some of the online slot machines that come to mind with cherry and fruit themes are Double Cherry, Lucky Cherry, Fruit Blaster and Fruit Shop, but there are many more.

Register with BetMGM and play classic online casino games and much more.

Actress Vanessa Hudgens flipping casino chips next to the text "The King of Casinos"
About the Author


Read More

Our BetMGM editors and authors are sports experts with a wealth of knowledge of the sports industry at all levels. Their coverage includes sports news, previews and predictions, fun facts, and betting.

Our BetMGM editors and authors are sports experts with a wealth of knowledge of the sports industry at all levels. Their coverage includes sports news, previews and predictions, fun facts, and betting.