When it comes to the NFL, fans spend months debating which athletes deserve the top draft picks. But what if Americans got to draft their ultimate fall comforts the same way?
In the Fall Comfort Draft from BetMGM Casino, Gen Z and Millennials picked their seasonal MVPs — and pumpkin spice lattes didn’t even make the roster.
BetMGM surveyed 1,500 Americans aged 18–34 and asked them to “draft” their top picks across seven cozy categories: celeb, drink, tradition, aesthetic, scent, entertainment, and overall vibe.
Key Findings
Here’s what young Americans say actually defines the perfect fall this season:
- The celebrity who best embodies fall? Taylor Swift (33%)
- Go-to fall drink? Hot chocolate (53%)
- Ideal tradition? A night in with a movie (23%)
- Top aesthetic? Cozy sweaters (56%)
- Most pleasing scent? Cinnamon/apple (29%)
- Favorite fall watch? Harry Potter movies (32%)
The Cozy-Season Winners, Ranked by Category
Fall Comfort Celebrity
- Taylor Swift
- Lana Del Rey
- Harry Styles
- Daniel Radcliffe
- Kristen Stewart
Meg Ryan, star of the iconic fall film “You’ve Got Mail”, received the fewest votes at just 5% – a surprise twist given her cozy rom-com legacy.
Fall Comfort Drink
- Hot chocolate
- Pumpkin spice latte
- Chai latte
Despite being TikTok’s recent seasonal hit, Maple Latte received the fewest votes. It seems this sweet-syrup trend isn’t the go-to for the majority, with only 3% choosing this viral drink.
Favorite Fall Tradition
- Night in and a movie
- Visiting a pumpkin patch
- Football Sundays
Corn mazes earned the lowest ranking, only garnering 3% of votes. It seems today’s fall crowd prefers streaming escapes over literal ones.
Top Fall Aesthetic
- Cozy sweaters
- Browns and burgundy
- Cowboy vibes
Leopard print received the least amount of votes at just 6%. Perhaps fall 2025 is more “low-effort layers” than loud statement pieces?
Favorite Fall Smell
- Cinnamon/apple
- Pumpkin spice
- Bonfire smoke
Surprisingly, baked pastries received the least amount of votes at just 13%.
Most Loved Fall Watch
- Harry Potter movies
- Hocus Pocus
- Twilight
“You’ve Got Mail” received the fewest votes with just 3%, a sign that young Americans’ idea of fall feels more like Hogwarts than the Upper West Side.
Closing Thoughts
Whatever your “draft” for fall looks like, there’s another great activity that you can add to your list that will keep you entertained on these increasingly chilly days: legal online gambling at BetMGM Casino.
BetMGM Casino has an incredible library of exciting, real-money online casino experiences, including online slots, arcade games, live dealer titles, and more. You can even take advantage of great promotions, including welcome bonuses or limited-time offers, when playing your favorite online game titles.
Register at BetMGM Casino to round off your draft with the perfect selection of online casino games and potential prizes.
Methodology
A nationally balanced sample of 1,500 Americans aged 18–34 was surveyed via Pollfish on 10th September 2025, and asked a total of 7 questions around the foods, drinks, traditions, and pop culture that define the fall season for them this year. Results were weighted by age, gender, and region to align with the U.S. Census benchmarks for this age group.
