The Cost Premium of Living Downtown Across the U.S.

• Table of contents
• Cities Where Buying Downtown Costs the Most
• Cities Where Downtown Rent Hits the Hardest
• America’s Most Expensive Downtowns
• Closing Thoughts
• Methodology

Even if the song was originally performed in 1965, Petula Clark was right, things will be great when you’re downtown. But living that close to the center of the city will cost you.

Whether it’s a trendy downtown loft or a historic home steps from the action, living close to the heartbeat of the city comes with a price tag that varies a bit depending on where you call home.

We analyzed home values and rent prices in America’s 100 largest cities, comparing downtown costs to surrounding residential areas. From sky-high prices in New York City to surprising downtown premiums in cities like Charleston and Toledo, our analysis reveals where city-center living demands the biggest investment.

Let’s dive into the numbers and see where living near the action is worth its weight in gold—or at least a few extra zeroes on the price tag.

If you dream of being in the center of the action, brace yourself — living downtown often comes with a hefty price tag. In some of America’s largest cities, downtown home values skyrocket compared to surrounding residential areas, reflecting the appeal of city-center living. Let’s take a closer look at the cities where home values experience the largest increases downtown. 

Cities With the Highest Downtown Home Value Premiums

1. Charleston, SC – 219.7%
2. Dallas, TX – 158.2%
3. New York, NY – 140.7%
4. Boston, MA – 134.4%
5. Virginia Beach, VA – 79.7%

Charleston leads the list with a staggering 219.7% increase in home values over the city’s average, likely due to the area’s historic charm, vibrant culture, and oceanfront appeal. In Dallas, rapid downtown development and a booming job market have driven urban home prices up by over 150%. Meanwhile, New York City and Boston remain perennial favorites, where limited space and high demand push prices as high as the skyscrapers that make up their downtown areas — 140% and 134%, respectively.

1. Virginia Beach, VA – 79.7%
2. Knoxville, TN – 76.7%
3. Detroit, MI – 73.4%
4. Greenville, SC – 65.7%
5. Austin, TX – 56.2%
6. Tampa, FL – 50.2%

Even cities like Detroit and Knoxville, associated with more affordable housing than some of the other cities in our list, show significant downtown premiums (both around 75% more than average home values in the area). This could be driven by revitalization efforts and growing interest in urban living. Coastal cities such as Virginia Beach and Tampa also command steep downtown price hikes, thanks largely to waterfront proximity and bustling tourism economies.

If you buy downtown, the convenience and lifestyle are going to cost you. Up next, we’ll explore where renting downtown costs the most — a reality many urbanites grapple with when balancing city life with affordability.

Even if you’re renting, living in the heart of a bustling city comes with a price. Across the U.S., residents in many urban hubs can expect to pay a premium for the access that downtown living brings. But where are those price increases the steepest?

Cities With the Highest Downtown Rent Premiums

1. Toledo, OH – 67.2%
2. Charleston, SC – 59.7%
3. Austin, TX – 55.6%
4. New York, NY – 51%
5. Chicago, IL – 36.1%

Interestingly, Toledo tops the list with a surprising 67.2% premium on down rents. Perhaps a sign that downtown revitalization projects and job growth have fueled renter demand. Austin and Chicago are both major urban hubs that make an appearance for cities with high rent increases while not cracking the top 10 for home value premiums. These might be cities that younger people flock to who aren’t quite ready to put a down payment on a home just yet. The inclusion of Charleston is less surprising when you consider just how much higher home values are downtown compared to the rest of the city.

1. Pittsburgh, PA – 32.4%
2. New Haven, CT – 32%
3. Tampa, FL – 30.4%
4. Dallas, TX – 29.5%
5. Knoxville, TN – 29.3%

Pittsburgh and New Haven both see about a 32% increase in rents in downtown areas compared to the rest of the city, good for sixth and seventh in our analysis, respectively. While neither may jump out as a city-dwellers dream, the rent premiums could be attributed to the general cost of living increases when you’re downtown and large surrounding metro areas where homebuyers typically prefer to settle down.

The trend is clear: access to downtown amenities comes at a steep price, whether you’re buying or renting. Next, we’ll explore the data in terms of dollars and cents rather than increases by checking out the cities with the highest overall prices for downtown living.

If there’s one thing we’ve learned so far it’s that if you’re dreaming of downtown living, be ready to pay a premium. Some of the U.S.’s largest metro areas command incredibly high costs, making downtown living a luxury reserved for those willing to spend. Here’s where living downtown will cost you the most overall, whether you’re buying or renting:

Cities With the Highest Downtown Home Values Overall:

1. Boston, MA – $1,625,948
2. New York, NY – $1,619,601
3. Charleston, SC – $1,397,414
4. Dallas, TX – $960,450
5. San Jose, CA – $879,435

Cities With the Highest Downtown Rents Overall:

1. New York, NY – $5,131
2. Boston, MA – $3,718
3. Charleston, SC – $3,278
4. San Jose, CA – $3,167
5. Los Angeles, CA – $3,000

Boston and New York City dominate both lists, reflecting their long-standing status as financial, cultural, and educational powerhouses. Limited housing supply and relentless demand have turned these cities into some of the priciest real estate markets in the world, especially for those who want to live downtown.

The appearance of Charleston on both lists shouldn’t come as much of a surprise when you remember how much the downtown living premiums were in the coastal city. To put it frankly, if you want those coveted downtown Charleston views you’re going to have to pay for it. Meanwhile, tech-driven cities like San Jose and Los Angeles boast sky-high rent prices, fueled by booming industries and strong rental demand from professionals drawn to Silicon Valley and Hollywood.

Downtown living may offer unbeatable convenience, but it comes with a serious price tag almost everywhere you look. Whether you’re eyeing a luxury loft or a trendy rental, be prepared to pay.

Closing Thoughts

Living downtown means being right where the action is but that kind of access comes at a price. And, in many cities, a steep one. Whether you’re buying a historic home in Charleston or renting a chic apartment in Boston, downtown living is a premium experience with a premium cost. The numbers prove that location really is everything.

At online casino powerhouse BetMGM, staying close to the action isn’t just a perk — it’s the whole point. Whether you’re playing your favorite legal money slots, exciting online casino games on the go or making a big bet from your living room, BetMGM keeps you connected to the excitement anytime, anywhere. (No rent or home value premiums required!) You can even save a little off the top by taking advantage of the casino welcome bonus offer for new players.

Methodology

To determine the cities where downtown living costs the most, we analyzed the average home values in America’s 100 largest cities and compared them to the home values in downtown zip codes in those cities.

We did the same thing for rent costs. All rental data is based on how much is paid per month.

The zip codes we used were the centralmost zip codes in downtown areas in every city. Where home or rental value data wasn’t available, we used the next-closest zip code for our comparisons.

All home value and rent cost data comes from Zillow and is accurate as of October 2024.